“It feels a lot like shouting at a concert, hoping the hottie singer on stage will see you”
Rebekah kritsch
So, just tried PitMad for the fourth time. If you are a writer and don’t know anything about PitMad, you can read it all here: https://pitchwars.org/pitmad/
It really is a strange experience. It does feel exactly like the quote above, and it feels worse too. There are so many pitches and one thing that it really does show you is that a lot of the advice you might receive as a writer doesn’t matter. You can have a wonderful pitch and not a single agent, publisher or even self-publishing publisher will pay it the slightest bit of attention. Or they may. One pitch will get seven agents/publishers drooling over it, while hundreds of similar, equally compelling pitches only get a bunch of retweets from other hopefuls spreading the love – as if they only want it when someone else wants it. It is utterly unpredictable. The only predictable aspect is that whatever mission the agents/publishing house is on will get more interest than other pitches. (i.e. If they’re on a mission to publish more middle grade, that gets the love. If it’s more non-fiction with STEM topics, that gets the love etc.)
I have had quite a few comments from people saying they want to read my proposed book, but all the likes I get are from other writers, never from agents. Even agents who have wishlists that match my pitches perfectly never like them, but like another pitch – that often doesn’t match their wishlist at all. And of course, if there is a trend going on, you are up against that too if you are not fitting in with that trend.
One of the biggest takeaways is that there are hundreds and hundreds of writers with great pitches. And just as many more without great pitches. And they are all bombarding agents/publishers every day.
I have read that more and more agents are abandoning PitMad and I understand why. It must be a bit like looking at an inbox you haven’t opened for 3 months. I imagine they find one or two pitches they like and that’s it. I mean, how many pitches do you want to look at if a whole bunch of these people are likely to query you directly anyhow? It’s not like you have to go out looking to find potential clients – you can find them anytime at all.
Every time I do PitchMad I think, that’s it, no more. But I still do it. It’s the gambling thing, I think. You might win big! But it’s really the same with querying, and if you don’t query, you won’t get anywhere at all. And of course, a pitch is at best a concept – having a good pitch doesn’t mean the liker will feel the same way about the book. You aren’t necessarily going to get a contract because an agent likes a pitch. And one of the good things about participating in #PitMad is that you do polish your elevator pitch until it shines, and that is a good thing.
I wish it was held on Fridays though. In this hemisphere, I can’t stay up all night to promote my pitch as I have to work the next day. That makes it hard to get as much attention as I could if I could really work on it all day. I also miss a lot of great pitches that I could retweet for others.
Anyway, thats PitMad September 2020 done and dusted. I hope some authors out there are living the dream from their efforts.